Who so ever is behind the Noida extension issue is against development of UP, NCR and spoiling the repo of India in entire world. Just think about what MNC's which might be planning to setup their centers here would be thinking by all this mess. Many who have already setup their offices might also start recosidering the decision. At the end NO companies...No Jobs so all Pvt company employees can go to Noida extension and start doing farming there under those farmers.
Read more
Reply
10 Replies
Sort by :Filter by :
  • Originally Posted by kirtikr
    Who so ever is behind the Noida extension issue is against development of UP, NCR and spoiling the repo of India in entire world. Just think about what MNC's which might be planning to setup their centers here would be thinking by all this mess. Many who have already setup their offices might also start recosidering the decision. At the end NO companies...No Jobs so all Pvt company employees can go to Noida extension and start doing farming there under those farmers.


    Kanoon Andha Hota hai- Law is blind
    CommentQuote
  • But us Rahul Baba aur Congress kyun dikhai de rahe hain..and ye andhapan achanak se election se pehle kaise jaag gaya...

    P.S> Just the way I hate Congress, I hate all other political parties
    Originally Posted by Totaram
    Kanoon Andha Hota hai- Law is blind
    CommentQuote
  • Eventually the builders will get the land, after all the construction work, land in Noida won't be suitable for agriculture a fact that farmers know, they are demanding a fair price for their land, which is not wrong.
    As for country's reputation, MNC's and other private companies aren't the largest generator of work in India, agriculture is it provides livelihood to 52% of India's population(in 2007).
    The compensation paid to farmers isn't even 1/10th of the quoted price of the land, the actual price is even more than the quoted price.
    CommentQuote
  • Originally Posted by VikramS18
    Eventually the builders will get the land, after all the construction work, land in Noida won't be suitable for agriculture a fact that farmers know, they are demanding a fair price for their land, which is not wrong.
    As for country's reputation, MNC's and other private companies aren't the largest generator of work in India, agriculture is it provides livelihood to 52% of India's population(in 2007).
    The compensation paid to farmers isn't even 1/10th of the quoted price of the land, the actual price is even more than the quoted price.


    Agruculture sector was so strong from centuries then why all these Malls, developments on surface were not before 2000...you can't ignore the contribution of these MNC...what was situation of Noida/Naoida based Villeges before 2000 you better know.

    It is not fight of Agriculture, it is only for to get money by unfair means, if the compensation was so below then why accepted that time, why not agitated, now why, because rate has been increased. how Authority would get money for Metro/Roads/Infrastructure, it is only by selling land, so always have the rate difference...I am deadly sure farmers were also not beneficial. they will also loose...only thing that there is some conspiracy, so these case were not presented in court seriously and lost.
    CommentQuote
  • Though farmers are not given adequate compensation but at the same time they can not be given the price they are asking for. In addition to upfront price, they also get 6% of developed land, annunity for 33 years or option of getting lumpsum money in lieu of annunity. Added together, this comes out to be thrice of the compensation that they are believed to be given.

    Besides, if GNA acquires land, all land is not allotted for housing projects. About 50% of acquired land is earmarked for road, open area, parks, public facilities etc.


    Originally Posted by VikramS18
    Eventually the builders will get the land, after all the construction work, land in Noida won't be suitable for agriculture a fact that farmers know, they are demanding a fair price for their land, which is not wrong.
    As for country's reputation, MNC's and other private companies aren't the largest generator of work in India, agriculture is it provides livelihood to 52% of India's population(in 2007).
    The compensation paid to farmers isn't even 1/10th of the quoted price of the land, the actual price is even more than the quoted price.
    CommentQuote
  • First Noida Authority should improve Noida

    Fisrt let them improve Noida...improve traffic, encroachments, hawkers...and other issues which we all face daily..then they can dream to create another Noida. I donot think anybody is against deleopment in UP. It is just law is blind. And justice always has someone who feels the justice is against him. But that is not the case.
    CommentQuote
  • Originally Posted by saprovo
    Fisrt let them improve Noida...improve traffic, encroachments, hawkers...and other issues which we all face daily..then they can dream to create another Noida. I donot think anybody is against deleopment in UP. It is just law is blind. And justice always has someone who feels the justice is against him. But that is not the case.


    Bhai saab. Noida cant develop..Noida was the largest exporter once upon a time..That title has been lost quite a few years ago. Bangalore, Pune, Gurgaon and now Chandigarh are becoming the hot shots now. The excellent infrastructure of G. Noida couldn't help attratct many IT companies. Look where is Pune now. Pathetic infrastructure but loads of IT and Auto investment. Central and U.P. govts themselves dont want to let it develop. I have already lost all hopes of getting a decent job in NCR and settle down there.

    Sholapur, Nashik and Kolhapur seem more profitable now.
    CommentQuote
  • You have a point saprovo.
    I understand ultimately the turn of events have not been favorable to we as middle class buyers. But, just give a thought to what would have been your reaction had you been in farmer's place - A very hypothetical situation - "govt. orders you to vacate your flat 20 years down the line at the rate at which you bought it 20 years back applying a certain law for acquisition. You are short of knowledge and money to fight your case as you are not too sure of the outcome. When you see other flatmates succeeding, you opt to lodge your case too and it works. You get your flat back. Isn't the outcome great for you and were you wrong by any means? no, not at all...you just got your hard earned flat back. And you dont mind selling it again at the going market rate".
    So, what wrong did farmers do then? I understand we are unfortunate buyers at the receiving end. We should not unnecessarily be hurting the farmer's sentiments. Court should consider we buyers as an affected party and deliver the best possible and swift judgment in our interest. Lets hope for the best!

    Originally Posted by saprovo
    Fisrt let them improve Noida...improve traffic, encroachments, hawkers...and other issues which we all face daily..then they can dream to create another Noida. I donot think anybody is against deleopment in UP. It is just law is blind. And justice always has someone who feels the justice is against him. But that is not the case.
    CommentQuote
  • The point here is HC shud ask Authority and UP govt to pay the extra compensation rather then the builders as these are the parties who are responsible
    CommentQuote
  • This is the way HC should decide judgement

    Originally Posted by kirtikr
    The point here is HC shud ask Authority and UP govt to pay the extra compensation rather then the builders as these are the parties who are responsible


    Wah kya baat kahi hai, Apne.
    Bilkul sahi.

    Now the court should order a practical judgement and not blind judgement. Practicallity demand that HC SHOULD ORDER GNA TO COMPENSATE THE FARMER BASED ON REASONABLE RATE.

    This is the best way to resolve the issue with every one happy. Ultimately it was fault of Greater Noida Development Authority (GNA).

    Historically too, there have been many verdict on this line, where every parties affected got something in return & were happy.

    ALL SHOULD TAKE THIS LINE ONLY.
    CommentQuote