Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

NPR - Northern Peripheral Road, Dwarka Expressway, Gurgaon Updates

Collapse
This is a sticky topic.
X
X
Collapse

NPR - Northern Peripheral Road, Dwarka Expressway, Gurgaon Updates

Last updated: 24 minutes ago
21863 | Posts
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Re : NPR - Northern Peripheral Road, Dwarka Expressway, Gurgaon Updates

    positive news sunte hi kai logo ki sulag jaati hain...

    Really cant understand the ideology of looking at every thing with doubt and negativity.

    Comment


    • Re : NPR - Northern Peripheral Road, Dwarka Expressway, Gurgaon Updates

      Originally posted by er.harjinder View Post
      Please find below the Latest copy of the Order for CWP 8055 of 2008 on 01-Dec-2014.
      carefully read the highlighted portion.

      http://phhc.gov.in:8080/pdf/io/CWP_8...ERIM_ORDER.pdf

      CWPs-8055-8060-8771-8697-8227-9265-12079-16712-2008, 12211-
      12545-16568-2009 and 9130-2014 (O&M)
      Jhanda Singh and others
      Vs
      Union of India and others
      Present:- Mr. Shailendra Jain, Senior Advocate,
      with Ms. Mannu Chaudhary, Advocate,
      Mr. Puneet Bali, Senior Advocate,
      with Ms. Monika Thakur, Advocate,
      for the petitioners.
      Mr. Ajay Gupta, Deputy Advocate General, Haryana.
      Mr. Arun Walia, Senior Advocate,
      with Mr. Ajay Narang, Advocate
      (in CWP Nos.8055 & 16712 of 2012 and 16568 of 2009),
      Mr. Ajay Nara, Advocate ( in CWP No. 9130 of 2014) for HUDA.
      Mr. Akshay Bhan, Sr. Advocate with
      Mr. Amandeep Singh,
      for respondent No. 7 in CM-14725-2014 in CWP-8060-2008.
      * * * *
      CM-14629-2014 in CWP-8055-2008
      CM-14678-2014 in CWP-9265-2008
      CM-14717-2014 in CWP-8060-2008
      CM-14723-2014 in CWP-12211-2009
      Leave is granted to place on record the additional affidavits of
      petitioner(s) along with annexures subject to all just exceptions.
      Applications stand allowed.
      CM-14725-2014 in CWP-8060-2008
      Leave is granted to place on record the reply of petitioner(s)
      along with annexures.
      Application stands allowed.
      CWPs-8055-8060-8771-8697-8227-9265-12079-16712-2008,12211-
      12545-16568-2009 and 9130-2014
      Learned counsel for the State submits that the Government is
      looking into the aspect of rehabilitation of the petitioners in various writ
      petitions and proposal in this regard would be placed before the Court on
      the next date of hearing
      . He prays for four weeks' time.
      On the other hand, Sh. Akshay Bhan, learned senior counsel
      appearing on behalf of respondent No.7 in CWP No. 8060 of 2008 submits
      -2-
      that 14 kilometers of the road has already been constructed and only four
      kilometers of road and that too in patches is to be constructed, however,
      because of the stay order road could not be constructed.
      Counsel for the State submits that a length of 1.3 kilometers is
      under stay whereas the rest of the road is under construction and is almost
      complete.

      Mr. Shailendra Jain, learned senior counsel for the petitioners
      has suggested alternative proposal to relocate the road. He will submit his
      proposal to the learned State counsel within a period of one week from
      today.

      Mr. Shailendra Jain, learned senior counsel further submits
      that some more cases arising from the same notification hav e not been
      listed. He would supply the number of those cases to the Registry and
      those cases also be listed on the next date of hearing along with these writ
      petitions.
      The State may consider the proposal regarding the
      rehabilitation of the petitioners or in the alternative the State may also
      consider other alternatives like determining the compensation under the
      ‘The Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition,
      Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013’. It is not necessary for the State
      to comply with the alternative(s) suggested by the Court and even if the
      same are not acceptable to the State the same will not come in the way of
      the respondents (HUDA).

      List on 14.01.2015.
      A copy of this order be placed on the files of connected cases.
      (ASHUTOSH MOHUNTA)
      ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE
      (HARINDER SINGH SIDHU)
      JUDGE
      01.12.2014


      So clearly the following facts are established infront of everyone....

      - Hon High court clearly in favour of Dwarka expressway development.
      - Final Proposal by Huda will be placed within four weeks time i.e. next hearing on 14-Jan-2015.
      - Status 14 km road is ready, now only 1.3 km road is left under litigation.
      - Matter is shifted to Hon. Special Bench and even Acting chief Justice is now in charge of the case.
      - Litigants now scared and thier lawyer trying to change the alignment (Defeat accepted, not challenging Dwarka expressway any more, As he knows that thier case is very week now).
      - Litigants to submit the report within a weeks time.
      - Court clearly suggesting some of alternatives but complusion for HUDA or State Govt to follow.
      So it is big landmak hearing I hope now Ulti ginti has started for the end of Litigation.

      Dwarka expressway is coming very soon......Now clear Sunlight is visible for the upcoming Sunrise :-)


      Cheers !!

      er.harjinder ji

      As usual you have come up with positive news

      I am so stuck on this statement in the order 'It is not necessary for the State to comply with the alternative(s) suggested by the Court and even if the same are not acceptable to the State the same will not come in the way of the respondents.'

      It clearly says that respondent (HUDA) has an advantage here. Even if Shailendra Jain submits a proposal. And even if it is acceptable to honorable court by any chance (And there are already 2 big 'ifs' here), HUDA doesn't have to agree to recommendations, and can chart its own path

      Petitioners are obviously fighting for realignment by claiming that even if 14 km is constructed, 4 km is not, so the road can be realigned. While HUDA claims that NPR is almost done, except for the 1.3 kms, so realignment doesn't make sense

      The above two put together shows that high court is actively looking at the business case of realignment, and if the business case doesn't stack up, the realignment proposal will be rejected and court will not stand in the way of DEW construction. Then HUDA will provide a rehabilitation or compensation which is fair as per the policies and that litigants WILL HAVE TO ACCEPT it

      Even if honorable court agrees to realignment, HUDA doesn't have to abide by it. Even here HUDA will provide a rehabilitation or compensation which is fair as per the policies and that litigants WILL HAVE TO ACCEPT it

      Power to take that call clearly lies with HUDA now. Hugely positive
      Last edited by ashu_sharmaa; December 3 2014, 07:37 AM.

      Comment


      • Re : NPR - Northern Peripheral Road, Dwarka Expressway, Gurgaon Updates

        I fully agree with above analysis and it appears positive, however some people just refuse to admit that anything positive can ever happen even in the face of clear facts

        I wonder what could be their motive ?

        Comment


        • Re : NPR - Northern Peripheral Road, Dwarka Expressway, Gurgaon Updates

          I don't understand why some people are misguiding and concluding the suggestion (not order) of court in its own way.

          The alternative here means exclusively for rehabilitation plan not for realignment option. Court is affirm to opt the realignment if its possible and may directed to HUDA whenever feels necessary and supporting evidence came in favor.
          Sab 99 ka fer hain............

          Comment


          • Re : NPR - Northern Peripheral Road, Dwarka Expressway, Gurgaon Updates

            Originally posted by nsd1445 View Post
            I fully agree with above analysis and it appears positive, however some people just refuse to admit that anything positive can ever happen even in the face of clear facts

            I wonder what could be their motive ?
            They don't just not admit to positives, but state things/ statements which are not even part of the order. And all with the purpose of spreading negativity


            All that is required to understand which way this is going is 'It is not necessary for the State to comply with the alternative(s) suggested by the Court and even if the same are not acceptable to the State the same will not come in the way of the respondents.'

            Court will not come in the way of respondents

            Comment


            • Re : NPR - Northern Peripheral Road, Dwarka Expressway, Gurgaon Updates

              Looking at the order posted and a simple understanding of English it is just a suggestion by Plaintiff's lawyer that he will present a realignment plan
              No where is it mentioned that the court has to abide by that or even give any importance or credence to the proposal.
              Maybe some people can see something that is not there, and would help if they could clarify how they came to the conclusion that the court has to abide by the plaintiff's realignment proposal

              Comment


              • Re : NPR - Northern Peripheral Road, Dwarka Expressway, Gurgaon Updates

                Originally posted by nsd1445 View Post
                Looking at the order posted and a simple understanding of English it is just a suggestion by Plaintiff's lawyer that he will present a realignment plan
                No where is it mentioned that the court has to abide by that or even give any importance or credence to the proposal.
                Maybe some people can see something that is not there, and would help if they could clarify how they came to the conclusion that the court has to abide by the plaintiff's realignment proposal
                Exactly the reason why it is called a realignment 'Proposal' and not a 'plan'

                But I expect some people to selectively ignore the fact
                Last edited by ashu_sharmaa; December 2 2014, 04:41 PM.

                Comment


                • Re : NPR - Northern Peripheral Road, Dwarka Expressway, Gurgaon Updates

                  MISGUIDING....MISGUIDING AND ONLY MISGUIDING....

                  Alternative suggestion is in different paragraph where only rehabilitation plan is pointed out....show me a single word where court state about realignment in this paragraph....its exclusively meant to rehabilitation alternatives not realignment proposals.

                  Realignment option has suggested to HUDA by petitioner lawyer (so far court has not given any view over it) on which their reply is awaited.....don't twist the words in your own favors......

                  The State may consider the proposal regarding the rehabilitation of the petitioners or in the alternative the State may also consider other alternatives like determining the compensation under the ‘The Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition,Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013’.

                  It is not necessary for the State to comply with the alternative(s) suggested by the Court and even if the same are not acceptable to the State the same will not come in the way of the respondents (HUDA).
                  Sab 99 ka fer hain............

                  Comment


                  • Re : NPR - Northern Peripheral Road, Dwarka Expressway, Gurgaon Updates

                    Earlier some people were claiming that they know everything but can not disclose the Case numbers and other details, now when clear facts are in front of everyone.

                    Do these negative guys left any face to show..??...still claiming false negativity.....(without any proofs again).They are claiming Huda don't have land in Gurgaon ...joke of the year....

                    We should think for next steps.....It is likely that following will happen...

                    1.Hon. Court is clearly with Government and HUDA........the false ownership of Power of Attorney etc will itself fall .....(At both Hon. High court and Hon. Supreme court).

                    2. It is clearly Public purpose (Roads & Highways)....it is not DLF kind of case where land was sold to developers ......the land is being used for Roads.....which is 88% completed.

                    3. All cases now connected ...why.....because govt. and Court is fed up with multiple cases at different dates........(Litigants & other negative People were misusing the legal system)

                    4. All the cases will be disposed off in next some of hearings.....being now heard through Special bench.......under the supervision of Acting Chief Justice....why.....to end all the cases for development.

                    5. At no point Hon. court is against Dwarka expressway but clearly suggesting to resolve the matter asap.

                    I think even the matter goes to Hon. Supreme court it would be resolved very quickly as it was unauthorized and illegal colony......even ownership is also false (POA)...in the best case only Registry owners will get plots.....As Hon. High court already mentioned in earlier judgement that POA can't be taken as proof of ownership. So when ownership is not proved so where is the point of compensation......It is court which runs on proofs..........


                    6. By no means illegal and unauthorized colony deserve the Price of (1,00,000 / sq yard)......at the max they will be given compensation at the Circle rate...which is hardly 20,000 / sq yard. Even the Circle rate of Palam Vihar (Authorised one has circle rate of 50,000 / sq yard).

                    So now with no room left for hiding facts for the negative people......(without any proof again as usual)

                    Wait for this golden time coming our way....

                    Cheers !!
                    Last edited by er.harjinder; December 2 2014, 06:26 PM.

                    Comment


                    • Re : NPR - Northern Peripheral Road, Dwarka Expressway, Gurgaon Updates

                      Don't let anyone's ignorance, hate, drama, or negativity stop you from being the best person you can be.

                      Comment

                      Have any questions or thoughts about this?
                      Working...
                      X