Hi All,

As has been happening for the last few days, Allahabad HC has begun putting stay orders on projects in NE. While I understand that this is currently happening in NE which was always risk-prone, still other areas of Noida can easily start coming into this ball of fire. This also includes sectors 7x and 1xx since the point of contention currently is the way in which the land was aquired and if the land use was changed from Industrial to residential.

Please note that we cannot get this information from our respective builders because they would show us their Lease agreement and other documents and not anything beyond that. I am sure most of us (belonging to IT, etc) would not even be able to decipher if the papers they are showing are the proper papers or not. In some cases, it might even happen that the builder papers are complete but still we run into trouble since the problem lied at NA end.

So the problem might not be at the builder end, but still we end users would suffer for not apparent fault of ours. Also, since most of us must have taken CLP or Flexi plans, the sooner we get to know about the real scene, the better it would be for us.

My question to you is :
1) Can we form a group and file an RTI seeking information for the land aquisition details in these sectors ?
2) Some of us may be working as Lawyers or in the Press or some Govt Agencies and using their credentials if they can get internal information from Noida Authority itself.
Read more
Reply
150 Replies
Sort by :Filter by :
  • Originally Posted by skoda0505
    Hi All,

    As has been happening for the last few days, Allahabad HC has begun putting stay orders on projects in NE. While I understand that this is currently happening in NE which was always risk-prone, still other areas of Noida can easily start coming into this ball of fire. This also includes sectors 7x and 1xx since the point of contention currently is the way in which the land was aquired and if the land use was changed from Industrial to residential.

    Please note that we cannot get this information from our respective builders because they would show us their Lease agreement and other documents and not anything beyond that. I am sure most of us (belonging to IT, etc) would not even be able to decipher if the papers they are showing are the proper papers or not. In some cases, it might even happen that the builder papers are complete but still we run into trouble since the problem lied at NA end.

    So the problem might not be at the builder end, but still we end users would suffer for not apparent fault of ours. Also, since most of us must have taken CLP or Flexi plans, the sooner we get to know about the real scene, the better it would be for us.

    My question to you is :
    1) Can we form a group and file an RTI seeking information for the land aquisition details in these sectors ?
    2) Some of us may be working as Lawyers or in the Press or some Govt Agencies and using their credentials if they can get internal information from Noida Authority itself.


    I am in it. Whatever support is required, i shall be there to provide it. We need to be fully aware of what is happening around.
    CommentQuote
  • Originally Posted by Munish Malhautra
    I am in it. Whatever support is required, i shall be there to provide it. We need to be fully aware of what is happening around.


    Same goes for me. I am in too! Hope more people join in, we can may be have a meeting and then collectively file an RTI
    CommentQuote
  • Originally Posted by skoda0505
    Hi All,

    As has been happening for the last few days, Allahabad HC has begun putting stay orders on projects in NE. While I understand that this is currently happening in NE which was always risk-prone, still other areas of Noida can easily start coming into this ball of fire. This also includes sectors 7x and 1xx since the point of contention currently is the way in which the land was aquired and if the land use was changed from Industrial to residential.

    Please note that we cannot get this information from our respective builders because they would show us their Lease agreement and other documents and not anything beyond that. I am sure most of us (belonging to IT, etc) would not even be able to decipher if the papers they are showing are the proper papers or not. In some cases, it might even happen that the builder papers are complete but still we run into trouble since the problem lied at NA end.

    So the problem might not be at the builder end, but still we end users would suffer for not apparent fault of ours. Also, since most of us must have taken CLP or Flexi plans, the sooner we get to know about the real scene, the better it would be for us.

    My question to you is :
    1) Can we form a group and file an RTI seeking information for the land aquisition details in these sectors ?
    2) Some of us may be working as Lawyers or in the Press or some Govt Agencies and using their credentials if they can get internal information from Noida Authority itself.



    Very noble idea. Count me in for any kind of support
    CommentQuote
  • Attached is the RTI form of NOIDA Authority.

    Can we name someone who would like to lead this forward? Or we drive it collectively?
    Attachments:
    CommentQuote
  • We can drive it collectively. Also do we have anyone from Press or Legal background here?
    CommentQuote
  • Originally Posted by skoda0505
    We can drive it collectively. Also do we have anyone from Press or Legal background here?


    That will be great if someone comes forward, but i doubt if someone will take that initiative. Anyway, We can decide on a day and collectively visit NA office with the RTI forms and submit them in a group.
    CommentQuote
  • Sounds good... Are you aware of the steps involved ?
    CommentQuote
  • Count me in also
    CommentQuote
  • RTI can be filed online also. Last year I did it to NOIDA authority on unlimited height. Online it took almost 6 month to get response.
    Site is rtination - File Right to Information act (RTI) applications online : From passport/income tax/provident fund delays to fighting corruption
    As company did not send it and told me that they sent it. Then I wrote negative on 3-4 website and forwarded them link then they sent it.

    But NOIDA authority ne taka sa jawab diya:

    https://www.indianrealestateforum.com/forum/city-forums/ncr-real-estate/noida-real-estate/8744-raised-rti-regarding-fire-safety/page2?t=11160&page=2
    CommentQuote
  • Count me as well
    CommentQuote
  • I am not really sure how helpful I can be , being out of country as of now but please do count me in . Do let me know how I can support.
    CommentQuote
  • Same case with me....I am out but count me in as well.
    CommentQuote
  • RTI reply will take at-least one month by authority. As per RTI rule... reply has to be provided within 30 days of application.. I am sure.. within 30 days of timeframe.. situation will be very changed...so better to check directly with Authority about current situation + RTI application for current situation.
    CommentQuote
  • You mean we follow the second point in my thread (try to get hold of some internal source and extract information out of him ) ?
    CommentQuote
  • RTI FORMAT

    Skoda0505. Filing a RTI is the best options. They are obliged to reply within 30 days as per the law. They can not skirt around the issue. Please make RTI elaborate.

    RTI should be structured in following way.

    To,
    The Chairman,
    Noida Authority
    Noida, Uttar Pradesh.

    Subject: Land use Status of Various Noida Sectors

    Dear Sir/Madam,

    We would like to know Land use status of following noida sectors 74,75,76,77,78,79,131,133,134,137,135,96,97,98,100,110,128,129,130,143,168, 150.

    For each of the sectors mentioned above please provide detailed explanations as decribed below.

    1) Please mentions under which clause of Land Acquisition act, land was acquired from farmers ?
    2) Please mention the cause (e.g. Residential development, SEZ, Industrial, Commercial, etc) for which land was acquired ?
    3) At the time of acquisition, did government heard and resolved objections raised by the farmers.
    4)In last 15 years, Did land use was changed. If yes, then please provide details of change of land use, date of change of land use.
    5) Please mentions if there are any ongoing litigation in Allahabad court regarding the land use or in-adequate compensation to the farmers.

    Best Regards
    XYZ
    Noida
    CommentQuote